Information

Single units vs ensemble recording for signal detection

Single units vs ensemble recording for signal detection



We are searching data for your request:

Forums and discussions:
Manuals and reference books:
Data from registers:
Wait the end of the search in all databases.
Upon completion, a link will appear to access the found materials.

I would like to know, when looking (in vivo electrophysiology) at response properties (latency, magnitude) in response to sensory stimuli, is there any advantage to looking at single units over ensembles of neurons? My ensemble data is really good, while my single units are only ok.

Any advice or resources regarding this would be helpful. I've talked to members of my lab, and looked for answers elsewhere, but havent really found what Im looking for.

Best!


First spike latency or similar measures when looking at ensembles only tells you about the latency of the least affected unit when you are talking about latency increases, or the most affected unit when you are talking about decreases.

For example, if you record from 30 cells on a multiunit cluster and the latencies of 29 of them increase but 1 does not change, you might conclude no effect on latency.

Also, changes in detection probability can be harder to recognize in multiunit recordings. If a pharmacological manipulation increases or reduces activity overall, including at distant sites, this might change your threshold of which cells' spikes you can accurately detect as spikes by increasing or decreasing the noise floor.

For example, if your threshold decreases, you might be recording spikes from ~20 cells in your control condition, but then sample from ~50 in your pharmacological manipulation. Note that in this circumstance the total number of spikes you record might actually go down, but you would underestimate the affect because you don't know how many cells you are actually sampling from.

Of course there are problems with single cell recordings too. Sometimes it's really the ensemble activity that matters more, in that case the single units aren't as informative. You also have the problem of tracking accurately a single unit throughout a pharmacological intervention, which can be problematic depending on the time course of the manipulation (electrodes drift, cells die) or if the manipulation itself affects spiking properties (it may be more difficult to ensure you have the same cell if spike widths or amplitudes change).


Watch the video: Performing IQ Data Capture and Playback (August 2022).